Israel - Topic

quote:
Originally posted by CHAS:
Daniel, Read the page you claim to be quoting again. Where does it say "slaughtered", or killed?

It doesn't. And it doesn't matter. My statement stands.

Posts: 12759 | Location: Williamsburg, VA | Registered: 19 July 2005

Ignored post by Piano*Dad posted

piqué

czarina
Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of piqué

posted

If the Arabs had accepted the UN partition in 1948, giving them their own country within Palestine, and refrained from attacking Israel, there would have been no Nakba.

Attack--without provocation--a community that has somehow managed to survive worldwide persecution--including the horrors of the Holocaust and pogroms--for 17 centuries and you may just get your ass handed to you.

"Never Again" also means "never again will we be helplessly slaughtered." No. We have an army now.

Anyone who throws around bullsh!t like that Israel killed 700,000 Palestinians in 1948 (and btw, there were no "Palestinians" in 1948. There were Arabs) is either ignorant or intent on fomenting anti-semitism or both.

Daniel, you are free to think whatever you like, but if it isn't based on the facts maybe you should just keep it to yourself rather than spreading lies that just contribute to more hatred in the world.

--------------------------------
fear is the thief of dreams

Posts: 21539 | Registered: 18 May 2005

Ignored post by piqué posted

Nina

Pinta & the Santa Maria
Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Nina

posted

I also think that irresponsibly using terms like "slaughter," "murder" doesn't help.

But Nakba did not result in 700,000 Arabs/Palestinians being killed. That's an antisemitic trope and easily refuted by even the most cursory research.

Posts: 35428 | Location: West: North and South! | Registered: 20 April 2005

Ignored post by Nina posted

Piano*Dad

"I've got morons on my team."

Mitt Romney
Minor Deity

posted

But that kind of research is beyond many people these days.

We can also point out that although 700K Palestinians were displaced (not "slaughtered"), some forcibly and many fleeing from the fighting, 750K Jews were displaced from Arab nations. Who has done a better job of resettling refugees and incorporating them into society? Who has languished in "camps" supported by UNWRA dependency-charity, shunned by many of their Arab neighbors.

Maybe some people should go to Wikipedia and look up Mizrahi Jews so they can actually learn something about Israel's founding and its in-gathering of the bulk of the Arabic-speaking Jewish population from North Africa and the Middle East.

Posts: 12759 | Location: Williamsburg, VA | Registered: 19 July 2005

Ignored post by Piano*Dad posted

Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Daniel

posted

quote:
Originally posted by QuirtEvans:
You have a right to your views and a right to express your views. But no one has to respect those views.

Either you be;over in Israel’s right to exist, or you do not. This is a fundamental question. If you do, it’s possible to discuss Israel’s actions in the context of, they live in the midst of an area where everyone wants to kill them, and how should they respond?

If you don’t believe in Israel’s right to exist, there’s no point in having a further conversation.

You're putting words in my mouth.

Besides, you might have noticed there are protests around the world

Plenty of people, Jews and non-Jews agree with my point of view.

Posts: 25325 | Registered: 31 March 2007

Ignored post by Daniel posted

Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Daniel

posted

quote:
Originally posted by CHAS:
Daniel, Read the page you claim to be quoting again. Where does it say "slaughtered", or killed?

I'm glad you (and others) have no problem with ethnic cleaning.

Posts: 25325 | Registered: 31 March 2007

Ignored post by Daniel posted

Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Daniel

posted

I said it was an error.

Here:

"According to the data documentation of www.palestineremembered.com, Israelis controlled 774 towns and villages during the Nakba. They destroyed 531 Palestinian towns and villages. Israeli forces atrocities also include more than 70 massacres against Palestinians killing 15,000 Palestinians during Nakba time."

Ethnic clensing and it is continuing to this day.

Posts: 25325 | Registered: 31 March 2007

Ignored post by Daniel posted

Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Daniel

posted

quote:
Originally posted by piqué:
If the Arabs had accepted the UN partition in 1948, giving them their own country within Palestine, and refrained from attacking Israel, there would have been no Nakba.

Attack--without provocation--a community that has somehow managed to survive worldwide persecution--including the horrors of the Holocaust and pogroms--for 17 centuries and you may just get your ass handed to you.

"Never Again" also means "never again will we be helplessly slaughtered." No. We have an army now.

Anyone who throws around bullsh!t like that Israel killed 700,000 Palestinians in 1948 (and btw, there were no "Palestinians" in 1948. There were Arabs) is either ignorant or intent on fomenting anti-semitism or both.

Daniel, you are free to think whatever you like, but if it isn't based on the facts maybe you should just keep it to yourself rather than spreading lies that just contribute to more hatred in the world.

Please stop with your smear campaigns. First I hated women and now I hate Jews?

Well, I can't say there isn't a [ridiculous] precedent to your accusation.

Half my family is Semitic.

Posts: 25325 | Registered: 31 March 2007

Ignored post by Daniel posted

piqué

czarina
Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of piqué

posted

quote:
Originally posted by Daniel:
quote:
Originally posted by QuirtEvans:
You have a right to your views and a right to express your views. But no one has to respect those views.

Either you be;over in Israel’s right to exist, or you do not. This is a fundamental question. If you do, it’s possible to discuss Israel’s actions in the context of, they live in the midst of an area where everyone wants to kill them, and how should they respond?

If you don’t believe in Israel’s right to exist, there’s no point in having a further conversation.

You're putting words in my mouth.

Besides, you might have noticed there are protests around the world

Plenty of people, Jews and non-Jews agree with my point of view.

Plenty of people have no idea what they are talking about and just take up the banner of their friends and associates without bothering to do their own research using valid sources of information.

--------------------------------
fear is the thief of dreams

Posts: 21539 | Registered: 18 May 2005

Ignored post by piqué posted

piqué

czarina
Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of piqué

posted

quote:
Originally posted by Daniel:
quote:
Originally posted by piqué:
If the Arabs had accepted the UN partition in 1948, giving them their own country within Palestine, and refrained from attacking Israel, there would have been no Nakba.

Attack--without provocation--a community that has somehow managed to survive worldwide persecution--including the horrors of the Holocaust and pogroms--for 17 centuries and you may just get your ass handed to you.

"Never Again" also means "never again will we be helplessly slaughtered." No. We have an army now.

Anyone who throws around bullsh!t like that Israel killed 700,000 Palestinians in 1948 (and btw, there were no "Palestinians" in 1948. There were Arabs) is either ignorant or intent on fomenting anti-semitism or both.

Daniel, you are free to think whatever you like, but if it isn't based on the facts maybe you should just keep it to yourself rather than spreading lies that just contribute to more hatred in the world.

Please stop with your smear campaigns. First I hated women and now I hate Jews?

Well, I can't say there isn't a [ridiculous] precedent to your accusation.

Half my family is Semitic.

Semitic? Or Jewish? Not always the same thing. And you have completely ignored the statements of fact that others have presented to you here and instead parrot buzzwords like "ethnic cleansing."

Nor have you answered Quirt's question.

--------------------------------
fear is the thief of dreams

Posts: 21539 | Registered: 18 May 2005

Ignored post by piqué posted

Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Daniel

posted

quote:
Originally posted by piqué:
quote:
Originally posted by Daniel:
quote:
Originally posted by piqué:
If the Arabs had accepted the UN partition in 1948, giving them their own country within Palestine, and refrained from attacking Israel, there would have been no Nakba.

Attack--without provocation--a community that has somehow managed to survive worldwide persecution--including the horrors of the Holocaust and pogroms--for 17 centuries and you may just get your ass handed to you.

"Never Again" also means "never again will we be helplessly slaughtered." No. We have an army now.

Anyone who throws around bullsh!t like that Israel killed 700,000 P alestinians in 1948 (and btw, there were no "Palestinians" in 1948. There were Arabs) is either ignorant or intent on fomenting anti-semitism or both.

Daniel, you are free to think whatever you like, but if it isn't based on the facts maybe you should just keep it to yourself rather than spreading lies that just contribute to more hatred in the world.

Please stop with your smear campaigns. First I hated women and now I hate Jews?

Well, I can't say there isn't a [ridiculous] precedent to your accusation.

Half my family is Semitic.

Semitic? Or Jewish? Not always the same thing. And you have completely ignored the statements of fact that others have presented to you here and instead parrot buzzwords like "ethnic cleansing."

Nor have you answered Quirt's question.

Both.

Posts: 25325 | Registered: 31 March 2007

Ignored post by Daniel posted

Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Daniel

posted

https://www.timesofisrael.com/...ies-elicits-outrage/

So cute.

Posts: 25325 | Registered: 31 March 2007

Ignored post by Daniel posted

CHAS

Has Achieved Nirvana

posted

I deleted two posts I made directed to Daniel since his last post.
If they show up on your screen please ignore them or ask a moderator to delete them.
I have contacted Daniel by pm.
He won't like
that private
post.

--------------------------------
Several people have eaten my cooking and survived.

Posts: 25850 | Location: Still living at 9000 feet in the High Rockies of Colorado | Registered: 20 April 2005

Ignored post by CHAS posted

Has Achieved Nirvana
Picture of Daniel

posted

quote:
Originally posted by CHAS:
I deleted two posts I made directed to Daniel since his last post.
If they show up on your screen please ignore them or ask a moderator to delete them.
I have contacted Daniel by pm.
He won't like
that private
post.

How rude.

Posts: 25325 | Registered: 31 March 2007

Ignored post by Daniel posted

CHAS

Has Achieved Nirvana

posted

You know rude.

Post the pm I sent to you. Then everyone will know you better.

--------------------------------
Several people have eaten my cooking and survived.

Posts: 25850 | Location: Still living at 9000 feet in the High Rockies of Colorado | Registered: 20 April 2005

Ignored post by CHAS posted