well-temperedforum.groupee.net The Well-Tempered Forum Off Key List of Movies that are better than the bookPage 1 2
Go | New | Find | Notify | Tools | Reply | |
| List of Movies that are better than the book | Login/Join |
Foregoing Vacation to Post |
So, IMO there are virtually zero movies that are better than the book they're based on. I can only think of ONE movie that's better than the book, and one other movie that seems to be better than the book. Movie is better: Forrest Gump Don't get me wrong here, I enjoyed the book immensely, but the changes made in the movie just make for a better story. Movie *might* be better: Hidden Figures I really like that movie so I went looking for the book. The only thing I could find was a comic book format ("graphic novel" kind of thing) and I couldn't make myself read it. So, if that movie is based on that comic book, even without reading it I'd lean towards saying the movie is better. What do you guys have? Any other movies that surpass the book? | ||
|
Has Achieved Nirvana |
Doug mentioned something about a Dallas and Debbie movie, but I cannot think of any.
| |||
|
Foregoing Vacation to Post |
I can’t think of too many movies that are better than the book. The only one that I can think of is “A Clockwork Orange”. The movie follows very closely to the book and if the movie isn’t better than the book, it’s at least equal to the book. The book and film complement each other well. It’s a novel about a dystopian future in which an out of control teen age gang runs rampant in Britain. The opening scene of the movie takes place in the Korova Milkbar. Its décor is something else. You have to see it to believe it. There are many Russian and slang words used in the movie and book although the book has more of them. The book has a glossary for these words. For the movie, don’t worry about it. You can understand what these words mean because of the context in which they’re used. For example, “droogs” means friends. | |||
|
| Has Achieved Nirvana |
Must agree. Stanley Kubrick is very good with making a visual impact. Have been a friend of Malcolm McDowell since IF. Sometimes the writing of Anthony Burgess seemed to indicate that he was getting paid by the word.
| |||
|
Minor Deity |
I always enjoyed Burgess' writing. Several of his books I liked a lot - Beard's Roman Women, 1985, I forget the rest. I was reading Burgess around 1980.
| |||
|
Gadfly |
I feel like the original Willie Wonka movie with Gene Wilder is better than the book. Been a long time since I read the book though. Also maybe Shawshank Redemption -- that's an amazing movie and I don't recall the book (which was really more of a novella) being anywhere near as good. Then again, it's hard to top Morgan Freeman in anything. | |||
|
| Pinta & the Santa Maria Has Achieved Nirvana  |
Hmmm, I'm struggling as well. I can think of a jillion where an amazing book was made into an awful movie (Oscar and Lucinda, anyone?), but not the opposite. Maybe some of the YA books, where the book itself isn't great, but the movie took the plot and made a visually impressive creation. I'm thinking of the Hunger Games series, for example. I was going to say "The Greatest Story Ever Told," but I didn't want to go to h*ll.  | |||
|
| Has Achieved Nirvana |
Brokeback Mountain came from a good short story. The movie changed a lot and added a lot for the better.
| |||
|
Beatification Candidate |
 Yeah, I saw that movie too, but I have no idea what book it was based on. Big Al
| |||
|
Has Achieved Nirvana |
I'll go with The Princess Bride. | |||
|
| Unrepentant Dork Gadfly  |
I was going to say the same! I agree about Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and Shawshank Redemption. On the Stephen King front I would consider adding Stand By Me to the list. The original story (The Body) was great, too, but the movie was better.
| |||
|
| Unrepentant Dork Gadfly |
Another one: Jaws.
| |||
|
| Beatification Candidate |
Perhaps my favorite movie and one that potentially falls within this category is Doctor Strangelove. The credits identify it as based on Red Alert, a pretty straightforward thriller by Peter George. Kubrick and George generated the initial screenplay, but the final result as reworked by that team plus Terry Southern became a very different beast, a black comedy instead of a thriller and the vehicle for what I regard as Peter Sellers finest moments. I suspect that there are other movies that so deviated from the source material that I'm unaware of the association. That one comes to mind both because of being my favorite and also being a Kubrick admirer for a lot of his work. Does anyone remember Paths of Glory? Big Al
| |||
|
Minor Deity |
On the Stephen King front I would consider adding Stand By Me to the list. The original story (The Body) was great, too, but the movie was better.[/QUOTE] My first thought. Excellent film and I think King has said his favorite film adaptation of his writing. Jf
| |||
|
| (self-titled) semi-posting lurker Minor Deity  |
Hmm, the movie Arrival is based on a short story, except I haven't read it.... But the visuals in the movie make me think that reading the same story would not be quite as good...
| |||
|
| Powered by Social Strata | Page 1 2 |
 | Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
|
well-temperedforum.groupee.net The Well-Tempered Forum Off Key List of Movies that are better than the book